Math Giraffe
  • Start Here
  • Blog
  • Doodle Notes
  • Shop
  • Classroom Management & Ideas
  • Algebra
  • Geometry
  • Middle School
  • Inquiry Learning
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Pre Algebra Doodle NoteBook
  • Finance Doodle NoteBook
  • Distance Math Activities
  • Start Here
  • Blog
  • Doodle Notes
  • Shop
  • Classroom Management & Ideas
  • Algebra
  • Geometry
  • Middle School
  • Inquiry Learning
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Pre Algebra Doodle NoteBook
  • Finance Doodle NoteBook
  • Distance Math Activities
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

Picture

3/18/2016 15 Comments

Going Over Math Homework

Going Over the Math Homework - How Much Time to Spend? Solutions and Options for Every Math Teacher's Biggest Dilemma
I feel like one of my biggest recurring teaching issues is the time spent going over homework.

I am constantly questioning myself whether I am spending enough time or too much, and it varies from one day to the next.

There are always students who need more time and want to go over every single problem and answer with full explanations.  And there are always a handful who are done after only 5 minutes, because they do not need to go over the homework at all.  

Does this mean that the homework was too hard or too easy?  Or that I should be giving different homework sets to different groups?  It is the one dilemma I can never quite feel satisfied about.  
Pin it
The time balance never seems quite right.  I don't have the perfect answer, but have noticed certain methods working better at certain times, and at least thought I could share some of the strategies I have tried.

As I struggled through each of these, I found the last strategy (the split end) to be the most versatile.  It's also one that takes a certain classroom culture, so it may not be right for everyone.  Here are the methods that can work in different situations.  I doubt I am alone in this struggle, but who knows!  Maybe it's just me.  Either way, I hope that trying one of these will help you feel that you are finding a better balance with homework review.  

Homework Partners

How it works:  Students have an assigned homework partner.  Desks are arranged in pairs.  It helps to keep the same partner for at least a month or so.  A full quarter is best.  A routine is set up, explained on the first day, and practiced starting on the second day of school.  Students get in a pattern of walking in, pulling out last night's homework immediately, and going over it with a partner.  They may not need to check each and every answer, but they get into the habit of planning ahead and circling difficult areas as they work.  They know that they will compare notes with their partners.  The key is to hold them accountable to themselves and their partners.  Reinforce the idea that they are helping each other to prepare for a test, and this is an intense tutoring time with one another to clear up any confusion.

When it's best:  
  • mature students
  • honors classes
  • situations when the answers are in the back of the book, but the math is higher level or the problems are complicated
Picture
How long it takes:  Once students get the hang of this procedure, they become pretty efficient.  The partner time can be limited to about 10 minutes, and then problems that were a challenge for everyone and cannot be cleared up in pairs can be addressed as a whole class.

Calling out Names

How it works:  The teacher calls on one student at a time to provide an answer, moving quickly through the rows.  Students put a star beside problems that they would like to ask about at the end.  After going through the answers quickly, and correcting in red pen, there is a chance to ask questions about any problem that students are not sure why they got it wrong.

When it's best: 
  • middle school courses with streaks of 20 questions that all have quick integer or fraction answers
  • classes that need to be held accountable out loud for showing that they have an answer and have completed the work
  • during the first weeks of school, when you can reference a seating chart to call as many student's names as possible to get to know them quickly at the beginning of the year (kill two birds with one stone!)

How long it takes:  Once you get into questions at the end, this can drag on longer than I like sometimes.  I have been known to cut them off and transfer the rest of homework checking into a split end strategy (see below) when I start losing a few bored students, but others still have questions.  Either way, keep the verbal answer portion moving quickly.  It should only take 3-4 minutes, unless you assign more than 30 problems.

Student Presentations

How it works:  Each student gets one problem assigned to present.  The teacher can assign the names along with the homework problems, or can choose randomly when it is time to present each problem.  The student comes to the board, solves the problem, and explains his/her method.  Points can be assigned based on the presentation (as an assessment or simply as a participation grade).  This method is great for helping students understand different approaches to the same problem.
Picture
When it's best:
  • ​in-depth problem solving (word problems)
  • combined with the verbal or self-check strategies (when the last few problems are word problems) - Assign 2-3 challenge problems per day, and rotate slowly through the whole class having one student present each challenge problem.
  • small classes

How long it takes:  This one can be the most time-intensive, but also can have the biggest payoff, for both the presenter and the class.  It's so beneficial for kids to see a different method, and a different explanation other than the teacher's.  Allow about 5 minutes per challenge problem. 

Self Check

How it works:  Students silently and quickly look over an answer sheet that is displayed or projected on a screen at the front of the room.  Each self-corrects his or her own work in a different colored pen.  You can leave time at the end for questions.

Even for classes that I usually do a different method, I pull this one out for special days when we have shortened classes.  It is super speedy when you are in a time crunch, but want to make sure everyone at least knows how they did and what to study.

When it's best:  
  • when time is short
  • students who are reliable and have a desire to fix their own answers for future success on tests
  • the material is review, or most questions have already been answered

How long it takes:  Potentially under 5 minutes (plus any time at the end that you reserve for questions)

Teacher Station

How it works:  On a day that students are working in learning stations, one station is the "teacher station," where a small group goes over the previous night's homework with the teacher.  Additional follow-up example problems should be on hand for extra practice together with any type of problem that the students in a particular group are struggling with.  Students can ask questions in a small group setting and work together and with the teacher to clear up confusion on the lesson.  

When it's best: 
  • classes with diverse students with different ability levels
  • classes that do learning stations once per chapter or lesson
  • teams that are grouped by ability
  • students that need extra teacher support in a smaller group setting

How long it takes:
  10 minutes, repeated with each small group, while others work on independent learning stations around the room.  This time is really maximized for big benefits because the time is intensely spent on each group's individual needs, and you have each student's full attention because of the small group setting.
Picture

Split End

How it works:  After spending a few minutes taking questions and going over the most needed homework problems, stop the homework review altogether.  Begin the new material, and proceed with your lesson as planned.  If additional homework time is needed at the end of class, allow students to split into two groups.  Those who "get it" move to the back of the room to begin a teacher-specified task.  Those who would like additional help with the previous homework or lesson (or need more review) move to the front of the room to work at the board with the teacher.  

I started this differentiation strategy after realizing that some periods I would spend almost 30-40 minutes going over homework, and never get to the lesson I planned because only a group of 5 students needed me to go over every single problem.

Once we developed a culture that worked for this, everyone was happy!  As long as no one is embarrassed to be in one group or another, they all feel that they are winning.  I was surprised at first to realize that the attitudes were not what I expected.  Those that need help feel that it's a privilege to get extra time with me, and those who don't need it feel that it's a privilege to go work on something else instead of sitting bored and feeling held back.  It made me wish that I had tried this sooner.  

​The reasons that I had always avoided splitting this way were far outweighed by the benefits.  And the challenges that I expected never came, because each student felt the freedom to decide what they needed.  I've tried this in middle school and high school, with great results and positive feedback from both groups of students.

I always let students self-select their own group.  If I see someone consistently making a poor choice of which group to join, I address it privately with that student outside of class time.

The students love this method, because everyone gets what they need.  The group in the back can get deeper into a critical thinking activity, work on an enrichment activity, or sometimes work ahead.  I vary it from one class to another.  I keep these groups flexible, because during one lesson, a student may be ready to move on, but in another topic feel totally lost.  Once students get used to the "split end" structure, they love it and gain confidence.  They also take great pride in self-assessing themselves correctly for each lesson, and knowing which area of the room to head to in order to set themselves up for success.

When it's best:  
  • a strong classroom culture that can support visible differentiation
  • students who can successfully self-assess their own level in order to group themselves according to their own needs
  • ability to self-direct (in back group)
  • variety of differentiated activities, resources, or problem sets available

How long it takes:  anywhere from 10 - 20 minutes  (It's not really worth splitting and getting re-settled for less than 10 minutes, in my experience)

I have had some success with mixing and matching these.  It helps to add variety and keep homework checking from becoming tedious.  Depending on the type of work, the group of students, etc.  I have changed up my methods from one day to the next.  This helps to keep the kids on their toes and accountable.

During any option, I also check homework for completion, and grade on a 4-point system, which you can read about here.

As for myself, I am feeling like I will never be fully satisfied with any one solution to going over homework that works well for every class and every topic, but my goal here is really to share as many options as possible.  These are the ones that I have tried, but please share what has worked best for you in the comments!  I'd love to collect more strategies for our math teacher community.  Thanks so much!
Pin it

To Read Next:

15 Comments
Valerie Basnett
4/5/2016 06:54:00 pm

How do you get your students to do homework?? At my school, homework is not graded because it's practice, which I agree with, but them students don't do it and they NEED the practice!!

Reply
Math Giraffe link
4/6/2016 08:46:12 am

Hi Valerie,
Wow, yeah, It would be so hard to accomplish without grading! It is practice, but I still feel that the effort needs to be rewarded. Here's how I grade homework:
http://www.mathgiraffe.com/blog/grading-homework-a-four-point-system
Can you do a similar point system and just count it towards a team competition with points rather than factoring it into a final grade? I doubt that would work in high school, but it may motivate some middle schoolers. Maybe? That is definitely a challenge!
Thanks!
-Brigid

Reply
Tonya
8/13/2018 09:48:28 am

Our parish has also moved to no completion grades allowed. Given that I also agree that homework is an opportunity for the students to practice and correct mistakes have you read or heard of other ways we could "grade"homework?

Math Giraffe link
8/13/2018 03:34:55 pm

Hi Tonya,
Can you do grades at all? Here are my thoughts on just giving a 1-4 score for trying it, but if that does not work, maybe just beef up your warm-up time to review the previous day through bellringer activities?
https://www.mathgiraffe.com/blog/grading-homework-a-four-point-system
Have a great school year!
-Brigid

Cynthia
5/28/2016 07:18:17 pm

I really like giving online homework two or three times a week. The kids get immediate feedback on each problem as they practice, which really helps their learning, and each student can proceed at his or her own pace... I use the IXL website for practice with specific skills that I assign, as well as MobyMax and Khan Academy for remediation and/or acceleration... I require the kids to work the problems on paper and turn in the work the next day, to prevent someone from just entering random answers, but no class time is needed for going over the problems. Also, the websites give me helpful data about the students' work.

Reply
Math Giraffe link
5/30/2016 04:16:47 pm

Hi Cynthia,
That's awesome! What a great way to do this. Thanks for sharing the specific online programs that you use. This is so helpful! This sounds like an awesome strategy to try. Thanks so much for the great idea!
- Brigid

Reply
Yani link
11/5/2016 10:50:07 am

I'm wondering if this will work with my second graders??? I love partners and split end strategies. I currently use the elbow or knee partners, since they sit in groups but I think assigning a special he partner for a month is interesting!!!

Reply
Math Giraffe link
11/6/2016 05:00:13 pm

Hi Yani,
Possibly! :)
I've never taught kids that young, but if they are good with working in partners already they may be able to get used to this process if you really model it well and they practice!! I hope it works.
Good luck! Let us know how it goes. Thanks!
-Brigid

Reply
Niki Marinaro
6/7/2017 04:48:54 pm

A HW review strategy that has worked for me with 4th and 5th graders is to have table groups. At the beginning of the year, I introduce and practice having students go through HW one problem at a time, with students taking turns reading out the answer they got. If all students have the same answer...perfect--they move on to the next question. If there are multiple answers, all students circle that problem and move on to the next one--here's the tricky part...I insist that they refrain from arguing or debating problems with different answers. After 3-4 minutes, I ask the whole class who needs to see or discuss any problems, and I only need to review those specific problems! I love this method because it gives me a few minutes to check in with individual students, give everyone credit for getting HW done, and allows me to see quickly when students have mastered a skill, or when I need to spend some time reteaching because most of the HW ends up being circled by a majority of students.

Reply
Math Giraffe link
6/9/2017 06:22:40 pm

Ooooh, I love this idea, Niki!
Thank you so much for sharing how you do this!
Awesome strategy! I am sure this will help a lot of people who are brainstorming new approaches. Thanks a ton! Have a great weekend!
-Brigid

Reply
Kris
7/15/2019 10:16:56 am

I do this same method in high school but I call it "fight for your answer" because if they have different answers I want them to discuss how they arrived at the answer. Usually they find their own mistakes and I don't have to spend as much time on the homework. They learn from finding their own mistakes.

Colleen
2/22/2018 10:42:22 am

I'm a parent, and I want to help my middle-school aged son learn how to check his homework for errors before turning it in. Do you have any ideas of how I can give him a systematic way of doing this?

Thanks :-)

Reply
Math Giraffe link
2/23/2018 09:01:45 am

Hi Colleen,
The textbook usually has answers in the back (at least for odd numbers), so that is a good place to start. For worksheets, etc. where that is not an option, you may want to try the app "photomath." Just give clear guidelines on when he can and cannot use it! :) I also always like kids to get plenty of reminders to check their notes! We do notes for a reason, and so many of them never use them effectively.
Thanks,
-Brigid

Reply
Judy Hante
7/16/2019 06:44:35 pm

I teach statistics to community college students. After a semester or two of reviewing homework in class, I realized that I couldn't spend the time unless it was maybe one problem nobody understood. I also now have my homework online in WebAssign, so I can see at a glance which problems are causing most students to lose points and can address the whole class proactively about those problems. I mostly give credit for completion rather than correctness. I like your ideas about homework partners right at the start of class, or posting the answers after the due date and having students self-correct. Both of these in combination might help my students tremendously. I also hold office hours, so they can come by as needed (or email or text me) to get homework help.
Thanks for always putting great ideas out there!

Reply
Math Giraffe link
7/18/2019 11:41:50 am

Hi Judy,
Yes, it gets to that point sometimes! You just can't take the time for every single problem.
I like the idea of online homework. That is so smart. Thanks so much for sharing!
So helpful! Have a great day,
-Brigid

Reply



Leave a Reply.


    Archives

    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    March 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    September 2021
    July 2021
    April 2021
    November 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    November 2019
    September 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014


    RSS Feed

    Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
    Click to set custom HTML
Proudly powered by Weebly
Photos used under Creative Commons from kellywritershouse, Robert-Herschede, University of the Fraser Valley, mrhayata, Iwan Gabovitch, nateOne, Franklin Park Library, rhymeswithsausage, US Department of Education, Edsel L, Larry1732, philwarren, peteselfchoose, Dean Hochman, BryonLippincott, AFS-USA Intercultural Programs, Nilsze, philosophygeek, VividImageInc, cantanima, dcysurfer / Dave Young